What's YOUR TAKE on this controversy?
Moderator: Shoshanah Marohn
-
- Posts: 6877
- Joined: 5 Jan 2005 1:01 am
- Location: Nanuet, NY
- Contact:
Think of it this way. We know how to to talk and we know how John Wayne talked. But few people can do a great imitation of John Wayne's speech patterns although most of us can do a very generic, cliche based imitation.
When playing, many of us can do cliche based imitations of our heros, but it takes a different kind of talent to nail it. Often the best imitators have no talent outside their imitation: think of Dana Carvey
When playing, many of us can do cliche based imitations of our heros, but it takes a different kind of talent to nail it. Often the best imitators have no talent outside their imitation: think of Dana Carvey
- Bent Romnes
- Posts: 5985
- Joined: 28 Feb 2007 2:35 pm
- Location: London,Ontario, Canada
- Contact:
Bill, the more I read your posts, the wiser I think you are.
BenRom Pedal Steel Guitars
https://www.facebook.com/groups/212050572323614/
https://www.facebook.com/groups/212050572323614/
-
- Posts: 1383
- Joined: 24 Sep 2003 12:01 am
- Location: Fort Worth, Texas, USA
Re:
BTW. Moony and Tom Brumley on thier Fender steels didn't sound too shaby either. And Chalker sounded the same back when he did big Hits on big steel on a Fender,as he did on any steel he ever had. Those guys could have made a electrified two by four sound like a black Emmons if they had wanted to.
- Uffe Edefuhr
- Posts: 149
- Joined: 26 Jan 2006 1:01 am
- Location: Sweden
- Johan Jansen
- Posts: 3328
- Joined: 4 Aug 1998 11:00 pm
- Location: Europe
- Contact:
- Bent Romnes
- Posts: 5985
- Joined: 28 Feb 2007 2:35 pm
- Location: London,Ontario, Canada
- Contact:
Johan, so nicely put, and very accurate.Johan Jansen wrote:And that's so nice about the pedalsteel:
What brand or modell you play, it will always sound like you! It belongs to the group of a few instruments, which sounds mirrors your mind and soul....
JJ
BenRom Pedal Steel Guitars
https://www.facebook.com/groups/212050572323614/
https://www.facebook.com/groups/212050572323614/
- Clete Ritta
- Posts: 2005
- Joined: 5 Jun 2009 6:58 pm
- Location: San Antonio, Texas
Two players are inspired by their heroes early on.
Player A loves Hero A and learns everything he can from his recordings.
Player B loves Hero B and does the same.
Neither player A nor B sound just like their heros, but the style and techniques they learn are different and reflect the heroes that inspired them.
A players style is based on what a player likes to play. This will usually include bits learned from the players he or she likes to listen to and has studied, and also new ideas developed from those learned skills.
Ray,
Sarah may sound like Lloyd to you because you hear her play in a style very similar to his. I think her equipment has very little to do with it, but you can bet that she was inspired by him!
Thats my take on the controversy.
I wonder who Lloyd's heroes were (when he was Player A)?
Hawaiian music of 1944 anyone?
...Lloyd Green was born on October 4 1937 in Leaf, Mississippi. He moved with his family to Mobile, Alabama at the age of four, where he began to take music lessons. At the age of seven he learned to play a Hawaiian string guitar..."
Clete
Player A loves Hero A and learns everything he can from his recordings.
Player B loves Hero B and does the same.
Neither player A nor B sound just like their heros, but the style and techniques they learn are different and reflect the heroes that inspired them.
A players style is based on what a player likes to play. This will usually include bits learned from the players he or she likes to listen to and has studied, and also new ideas developed from those learned skills.
Ray,
Sarah may sound like Lloyd to you because you hear her play in a style very similar to his. I think her equipment has very little to do with it, but you can bet that she was inspired by him!
Thats my take on the controversy.
I wonder who Lloyd's heroes were (when he was Player A)?
Hawaiian music of 1944 anyone?
...Lloyd Green was born on October 4 1937 in Leaf, Mississippi. He moved with his family to Mobile, Alabama at the age of four, where he began to take music lessons. At the age of seven he learned to play a Hawaiian string guitar..."
Clete
- Ron Davis
- Posts: 580
- Joined: 8 Aug 2010 1:24 pm
- Location: Lake Arrowhead, California... We're a mile high. ;)
I'm a total newb on psg, but have played drums for 45 years & guitar for 37...
When playing "covers", I have always had folks comment on how well I can sound like the players who's songs I'd play.
In a nutshell, for me, it's all about "feeling" what I feel while listening to those players. That seems to enable be to sorta cop the same vibe/attitude as whatever I'm "reproducing". Then it's easier to cop their feel, pocket & even easier to play their licks.
Then, it's like owning it because I'm "feeling" it.
If I don't fall into that particular "vibe", then it ain't right. So over the years, that has become my thing. I just get into that state of mind, feel, vibe, etc., & crooz on through. Makes it fun... always.
Studying their style/chops, etc., is of course a must, but I know players who can learn to copy stuff note for note, beat for beat, etc., but can never sound at all like the player they're seeking to emulate.
Ya gotta feel it... It's really a state of mind.
Just my 2 cents.
Now if I can just learn how to play this psg worth a darned, I can have some more fun.
rd
When playing "covers", I have always had folks comment on how well I can sound like the players who's songs I'd play.
In a nutshell, for me, it's all about "feeling" what I feel while listening to those players. That seems to enable be to sorta cop the same vibe/attitude as whatever I'm "reproducing". Then it's easier to cop their feel, pocket & even easier to play their licks.
Then, it's like owning it because I'm "feeling" it.
If I don't fall into that particular "vibe", then it ain't right. So over the years, that has become my thing. I just get into that state of mind, feel, vibe, etc., & crooz on through. Makes it fun... always.
Studying their style/chops, etc., is of course a must, but I know players who can learn to copy stuff note for note, beat for beat, etc., but can never sound at all like the player they're seeking to emulate.
Ya gotta feel it... It's really a state of mind.
Just my 2 cents.
Now if I can just learn how to play this psg worth a darned, I can have some more fun.
rd
Emmons 12 p/p, Revelation, Black Widows, (& way too many assorted goodies...)
Drummer with a pedal steel fantasy.
www.LA-Zep.com
www.Desperado1.com
www.CMWChicagoTribute.com
Drummer with a pedal steel fantasy.
www.LA-Zep.com
www.Desperado1.com
www.CMWChicagoTribute.com
- James Martin (U.K.)
- Posts: 539
- Joined: 2 Nov 2004 1:01 am
- Location: Watford, Herts, United Kingdom * R.I.P.
- Alan Brookes
- Posts: 13218
- Joined: 29 Mar 2006 1:01 am
- Location: Brummy living in Southern California
I don't think we learn much from listening to other steel players. We learn more from watching and imitating them, and not even videos are much help there, because you rarely get to see a view of the player's feet, knees and hands at the same time. To sound like Lloyd Green you would have to take instruction from Lloyd Green, and have his talent. Even then, you would introduce something of yourself into your playing. A lot of picking style is picked up by accident. You're just messing around on the steel and suddenly you play something, and think "that sounds good", and you repeat it. Before long it's part of your style.
I think most steel guitarists are self-taught, and they get stuck in their own riffs until they figure out a few more.
There are so many steel guitarists out there that there are bound to be some that sound like others, just statistically alone.
Remember what Jerry said about the guy who was pestering him to buy his guitar. Jerry eventually sold it to him, and shortly afterwards he called Jerry on the phone to ask why it sounded different, and Jerry's response was, "You're not me..."
I think most steel guitarists are self-taught, and they get stuck in their own riffs until they figure out a few more.
There are so many steel guitarists out there that there are bound to be some that sound like others, just statistically alone.
Remember what Jerry said about the guy who was pestering him to buy his guitar. Jerry eventually sold it to him, and shortly afterwards he called Jerry on the phone to ask why it sounded different, and Jerry's response was, "You're not me..."
Re: Your comments are interesting and appreciated!
I taught Sarah Jory to play pedal steel guitar from a very young age, and her objective was very clear from the outset - "I want to play like Lloyd Green". You can show people how to play the same notes as someone else but it down to them to play with the same emotion and feel.Ray Montee wrote:But if all that's been said here......were gospel
HOW IS IT that Sarah Jory has a sound nearly identical to Lloyd Green?
I'm not talking about style here, I'm referring specifically to THE SOUND! Is SHO-BUD? Is the amp? Is it his black box?
You tell me!
It is not always about equipment. I personally don't think that there is anyone who can emulate him perfectly as he is a unique stylist. I agree totally with Herb Steiner, particularly with reference to Lloyd's bar control.
Show Pro D10 - amber (8+6), MSA D10 Legend XL Signature - redburst (9+6), Infinity SD10 (4+5) Sho-Bud Pro 111 Custom (8+6), Emmons black Push-Pull D10 (8+5), Zum D10 (8x8), Hudson pedal resonator. Telonics TCA-500, Webb 614-E,
-
- Posts: 1383
- Joined: 24 Sep 2003 12:01 am
- Location: Fort Worth, Texas, USA
Re:
Curly Chalker once said you spend all that time setting your amp to get the tone you want and it only takes a minute or two for a sound man to screw it up. Go figure.
-
- Posts: 6429
- Joined: 22 Jul 2003 12:01 am
- Location: Bradford, Pa. Frozen Tundra
-
- Posts: 394
- Joined: 12 Jul 2008 1:30 pm
- Location: Cortez, Colorado, USA
Great artists are great in part because they are unique. Wouldn't it be nice if someone were copying you or me because we have our own sound someone felt was worth imitating.
I have always considered learning intros, solos etc "just like the record", a way to build my musical vocabulary and thereby raise my performance level. However, I don't consider that an end in itself. I tend to play my own style which may or may not work depending on the situation. I have a tone and action I am comfortable with and that fits the music I am playing.
I can't help but remember a friend voicing his frustration because the band he was in wanted him to play like Paul Franklin. My friend is a FINE steel player but he didn't last too long in that band.
I have always considered learning intros, solos etc "just like the record", a way to build my musical vocabulary and thereby raise my performance level. However, I don't consider that an end in itself. I tend to play my own style which may or may not work depending on the situation. I have a tone and action I am comfortable with and that fits the music I am playing.
I can't help but remember a friend voicing his frustration because the band he was in wanted him to play like Paul Franklin. My friend is a FINE steel player but he didn't last too long in that band.
-
- Posts: 12505
- Joined: 4 Aug 1998 11:00 pm
- Location: Spicewood TX 78669
- Contact:
Ellis, you have a correct and a mature outlook about your playing and music in general.Ellis Miller wrote: I have always considered learning intros, solos etc "just like the record", a way to build my musical vocabulary and thereby raise my performance level. However, I don't consider that an end in itself. I tend to play my own style which may or may not work depending on the situation. I have a tone and action I am comfortable with and that fits the music I am playing.
I have no doubt that the guitarist plays just like Brent Mason, the singer just like (insert current hot favorite, male and/or female), and that they probably have the creativity of a small soap dish.I can't help but remember a friend voicing his frustration because the band he was in wanted him to play like Paul Franklin. My friend is a FINE steel player but he didn't last too long in that band.
My rig: Infinity and Telonics.
Son, we live in a world with walls, and those walls have to be guarded by men with steel guitars. Who's gonna do it? You? You, Lt. Weinberg?
Son, we live in a world with walls, and those walls have to be guarded by men with steel guitars. Who's gonna do it? You? You, Lt. Weinberg?
- Walter Stettner
- Posts: 5744
- Joined: 21 Nov 2003 1:01 am
- Location: Vienna, Austria
- Contact:
It is interesting to me that this topic in general is often brought up by musicians. Music, as a creative art form, is similar to painting, building architecture, writing literature and many other fields of art but I have hardly ever heard of painters or writers who were trying to paint or write specifically like one of the famous idols (unless for a specific reason).
I always compare playing steel guitar (or any other music instrument) to learning a language. You need a certain level of technical skills (for a language that would be grammar and vocabulary) but you will never really be 100% at home in a new language until you start to THINK in that language. Our steel guitar idols like Lloyd Green, Buddy Emmons, Jerry Byrd and so many others have taken that important step. Many of us are trying to learn the licks, intros and solos from records or tabulature but end up disappointed because the result is still different from the original. No wonder - you all don't have the same brain and same way of thinking musically like the player who did the original. There are other components, too, like the steel, the amp and a few other things, but the majority comes from the musician's inner feelings, his heart and brain (no other way to describe it for me).
Kind Regards, Walter
I always compare playing steel guitar (or any other music instrument) to learning a language. You need a certain level of technical skills (for a language that would be grammar and vocabulary) but you will never really be 100% at home in a new language until you start to THINK in that language. Our steel guitar idols like Lloyd Green, Buddy Emmons, Jerry Byrd and so many others have taken that important step. Many of us are trying to learn the licks, intros and solos from records or tabulature but end up disappointed because the result is still different from the original. No wonder - you all don't have the same brain and same way of thinking musically like the player who did the original. There are other components, too, like the steel, the amp and a few other things, but the majority comes from the musician's inner feelings, his heart and brain (no other way to describe it for me).
Kind Regards, Walter
Walter, in fact many of the great artist in any media have spent significant time copying their heroes. Van Gogh emulated Millet. Picasso is another who copied (he copied Rembrandt). William Faulkner emulated his heroes (Conrad, Joyce). It is part of the process of formulating one's own style. It's also about learning when to let go and become yourself.
Very well stated and very appropo.Mike Neer wrote:Walter, in fact many of the great artist in any media have spent significant time copying their heroes. Van Gogh emulated Millet. Picasso is another who copied (he copied Rembrandt). William Faulkner emulated his heroes (Conrad, Joyce). It is part of the process of formulating one's own style. It's also about learning when to let go and become yourself.
c.
A broken heart + †= a new heart.
- Walter Stettner
- Posts: 5744
- Joined: 21 Nov 2003 1:01 am
- Location: Vienna, Austria
- Contact:
Mike, you are right, even our heroes are free to admit that they were influenced by others and learned from them but they used the influence to develope a style of their own and didn't stop there without moving on to their own style which often turned into something new and different. My point is that, more or less, everybody should try to come to his/her own style - and that is something that should come from within yourself. A long time ago I tried to learn some of Lloyd's famous steel parts, but I learned very fast that this wouldn't get me anywhere. Lloyd and Buddy and Jerry (and all the other legend players) added such a great deal of personality to their playing that it is almost impossible to follow them. If I play a Lloyd Green lick, it never comes even close to the original...
Kind Regards, Walter
Kind Regards, Walter
- Clete Ritta
- Posts: 2005
- Joined: 5 Jun 2009 6:58 pm
- Location: San Antonio, Texas
Hawaiian players, Grand Ole Opry and probably Jerry Byrd, if I remember correctly.Clete Ritta wrote:Nobody replied to my off topic question, but I'll bet that there's a little bit of Lloyd's heroes in his style. Anyone know who Mr. Green was inspired by when he was, let's say...14 years old in 1951?...I wonder who Lloyd's heroes were...?
Clete
- Bob Hoffnar
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: 4 Aug 1998 11:00 pm
- Location: Austin, Tx
- Contact:
Walter, I guess I have a different opinion about that. Some of my absolute favorite steel players working in Texas are really not interested in having a style of there own. They are concerned with keeping the music they love alive. Hearing a guy nailing the Weldon kick off to "I'll Come Running" with Amber Digby singing at an old dance hall is pretty exciting and deeply musical stuff !My point is that, more or less, everybody should try to come to his/her own style - and that is something that should come from within yourself.
Bob
- Clete Ritta
- Posts: 2005
- Joined: 5 Jun 2009 6:58 pm
- Location: San Antonio, Texas
Thanks Mike,
I had a feeling Jerry Byrd might be mentioned. Maybe Ray Montee (the OP) can shed some light on this, as he is way more familiar with both Lloyd and Jerry than I will ever be. Do you hear things Lloyd played that he may have picked up from Jerry? Maybe very early on in his career?
Im trying to get back to the heart of the matter: the influence and style parallax.
Clete
I had a feeling Jerry Byrd might be mentioned. Maybe Ray Montee (the OP) can shed some light on this, as he is way more familiar with both Lloyd and Jerry than I will ever be. Do you hear things Lloyd played that he may have picked up from Jerry? Maybe very early on in his career?
Im trying to get back to the heart of the matter: the influence and style parallax.
Clete
- Allan Jirik
- Posts: 391
- Joined: 16 Feb 2010 3:45 pm
- Location: Wichita Falls TX
- Alan Harrison
- Posts: 589
- Joined: 17 Apr 2005 12:01 am
- Location: Murfreesboro Tennessee, USA
I lack talent!
As much as I admire the great players who do the studio work and travel with the stars and play many difference types of music, I have never tried to copy exactly another players licks. I don't have the talent.
I can kick off, and or play a break on almost any song I hear. However, I have enough trouble sounding like Alan. And I know that there is only one Buddy E, Randy B or Johnny Cox etc. I'm just pretty darn happy just playing like ME.
I can kick off, and or play a break on almost any song I hear. However, I have enough trouble sounding like Alan. And I know that there is only one Buddy E, Randy B or Johnny Cox etc. I'm just pretty darn happy just playing like ME.
Mullen (Black) Pre G-2 9x7, B.L. 705 PUP's, Evans SE 200 Telonics NEO 15-4, BJS Bar, Peterson Strobo Flip, Steelers Choice Seat, Folgers Coffee and Hilton Pedals.
"I Steel Without Remorse"
"I Steel Without Remorse"