The Steel Guitar Forum

Curious about this for sure and apologies if it’s been covered ad nauseam before, I searched etc...
I have always had the change on LKR but have been wondering about RKL (which currently flats B’s) I don’t tend to use the change-lok and have a one-big-tuning approach.
‘03 Sierra session u12
Uni-peeps let’s go!

RKL, the only and best way. JMHO. Your left feet is free to go abc45678 easily. I have the change lock on my U12 Carter. Never use it. My B to Bb change is LKV.

E raises and E lowers on separate knees for me. I wound up with E=>Eb on RKL, regardless of U12 E9/B6, Ext E9, or standard E9 for me. I think it's a total no-brainer on universal, but I think it's a winning argument on any setup for me.

Buddy Emmons and Paul Franklin dissected the pros and cons of same knee vs. split knees for the books here - https://bb.steelguitarforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=29594 - there have been dozens of discussions over the nearly 25 years of the forum, and that thread is, IMO, one-stop shopping on this subject. Read the whole thread.

Now, bodies are different and thus the ergonomics may be different for different people. I personally find it less natural for my knees to move outward than inward, and the E=>Eb is used so much that I want it to be in the most natural position for me - RKL. But that is reversed for some players. So YMMV.

There is no 'right' answer. More than 15 years ago, I tried every permutation on a real easy-to-set-up old BMI. It took a few months of continuous tearing down and setting up, and I think it was worth the trouble. For me, at least.

RKL. For general Universal and 'one big tuning' purposes and also for use, specifically, to split the E raises & lowers. If I were starting over I might consider RKR instead of RKL but I have zero interest in relearning stuff now.

LKR works well for me

RKL for me too. I learned that way, and it just seems that (especially on a Universal) when you engage the E>Eb lever you leave it in for much longer than any other KL. I can't imagine holding that change on LKR while having to dance on all the pedals with the left foot; the B6 side can be a stretch. Makes sense to pair the E>Eb change with the right foot, which is usually parked on the VP. No problem controlling the volume with RKL or RKR engaged.

RKR for me. Easier to hold it there for more extensive playing in th 6th mode.

John De Maille wrote:RKR for me. Easier to hold it there for more extensive playing in th 6th mode.

Me too, and raise Es on LKR

I do RKL with no lock. While I mostly play with my right foot on the volume pedal, this configuration allows me to comfortably move my right foot to the B6 pedals as needed while lowering the E's.

Hey y’all thank you for your replies! And thanks Dave for blowing the dust off that old thread- very informative. I’m sold on it and am gonna take the plunge!

I played a MSA S10 With Days Set Up, LKL Lower E's, LKR Raised E's, From 1999 to 2017.

I bought a S12U, There was some Jeff Newman lessons on Pedals, Knee levers and B6th in the deal.
When I bought the GFI S12 it was Set up Emmons/Nashville.

I changed The guitar to Day Set Up. While working on the guitar I Changed the kL's to Jeff Newman's Copendent. RKL Raise 4-8-11 to F. RKR Lower 4-8 to D# and 2 to C#.

It took just a few days and the knee levers was no problem. On the 12U Newman U tuning, the (10th String B) is on the (9th string B). Playing Strings 6-8-9 instead of 6-8-10, Took some serious practice to get that move into my Neuro-Memory.

The 9th B- 10th G#- 11th E on The Newman Uni Copendent opens some new ground to explore too.
"He Stopped Loving Her Today" has possibilities.

If you jump, Good Luck and Happy Steelin.

RKL

Here are some pics of a Mullen I played for many years.

https://bb.steelguitarforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=161579

~Lee

Once you pick the position of the E Lower knee lever.
You may want to consider placing the Pull Rod Closer to the Cross rod in the Bell Crank. This means a longer travel on the KL, But less force to keep it engaged.
Good Luck and Happy Steelin.

Edited: Was looking at my computer not my guitar.

RKR Eb
RKL F
For the past 50yrs.

RKR Lowers E's.
LKL Raises E's.

I played for a number of years with RKL. I switched to RKR where it is now. The muscles in your leg are able to hold the RKR longer because they are stronger than the ones used for RKL. And they don't affect your left leg as much IMO. Thats why I do RKR. Other than that, its just a matter of personal preference. Even though I have been using RKR for quite a while, I still find myself trying to use RKL on those songs I learned years ago from time to time.

RKL E's
RKR F's

RKL - lower E to Eb
LKL - raise E to F

E --> Eb = RKR
E --> F = LKR

I play Day setup CBA, so E-->F follows the A pedal.

I use RKL. The old Sho-Bud configuration on my Carter U12.
And the reason is because if I need p5 and p7, the right foot can come into play without too much movement.