What key is "Sweet Home Alabama" in?
Moderators: Dave Mudgett, Janice Brooks
- Steve Green
- Posts: 837
- Joined: 11 Oct 2010 11:28 am
- Location: Gulfport, MS, USA
- Contact:
What key is "Sweet Home Alabama" in?
If someone plays Skynyrd's "Sweet Home Alabama" using the chord progression: D - C - G - G
Would that be considered in the Key of G, with the chord structure as follows:
5 - 4 - 1 - 1
Or would it be considered in the key of D, with the chord structure as follows:
1 - b7 - 4 - 4
Would that be considered in the Key of G, with the chord structure as follows:
5 - 4 - 1 - 1
Or would it be considered in the key of D, with the chord structure as follows:
1 - b7 - 4 - 4
-
- Posts: 3009
- Joined: 1 Dec 1998 1:01 am
- Location: LA,CA
- John Booth
- Posts: 2036
- Joined: 25 Oct 2014 9:17 am
- Location: Columbus Ohio, USA
- Jeff Garden
- Posts: 3645
- Joined: 21 Aug 2003 12:01 am
- Location: Center Sandwich, New Hampshire, USA
You're evidently not the first person to ask,Steve Here's a rather lengthy discussion with some interesting points from the Joe Bonamassa guitar forum. Looks like most people agree it's in D...
http://forum.jbonamassa.com/viewtopic.php?id=6695
http://forum.jbonamassa.com/viewtopic.php?id=6695
- Rich Upright
- Posts: 1183
- Joined: 30 Sep 2014 9:55 am
- Location: Florida, USA
- Dave Mudgett
- Moderator
- Posts: 9648
- Joined: 16 Jul 2004 12:01 am
- Location: Central Pennsylvania and Gallatin, Tennessee
Man, we've had some old-argument threads the last few days. The decision about whether to call SHA D or G will never be resolved to everyone's satisfaction, depending on how you think about the concept of 'home', 'key', and 'key signature'. I say you can look at it either way, D or G. For example, see http://bb.steelguitarforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=153174 - but YMMV. Some people are gonna insist it has to be D. Others are gonna insist it has to be G.
If I was talking to a rock and roll or blues guitarist, I'd tell them D - 1, b7, 4, and based on the blues or mixolydian scale if they knew what that meant. On the other hand, a piano player reading from a score would be reading using a G key signature, then it's 5, 4, 1. I think it's useful to be able to think about it both ways. In fact if you listen to the original, I think it's clear that different soloists were effectively (by their choice of notes) thinking about it different ways.
It's generally annotated in G - think "Play the Greatest Hits for Piano" book type of thing. This leads to the most efficient transcription. That's great, but not the only way to think about it. In most situations, I think about it as in D and based on a blues/mixolydian scale. But I started out as a blues guitarist, and think about a 1, b7, 4 type of progression as being keyed in the 1 chord. When I form a mental image, I'm thinking about choosing the scale notes from D mixolydian, although I admit I'm not thinking modes, that's just a the particular mode that goes with the notes that "go over" that song. But even that doesn't really cover it - the blue notes modify that thinking.
I would take bets that Skynyrd was not reading this song from a score, and I doubt they ever have. But if a symphony played it (shudder the thought!), I bet they'd be reading a score in G.
If I was talking to a rock and roll or blues guitarist, I'd tell them D - 1, b7, 4, and based on the blues or mixolydian scale if they knew what that meant. On the other hand, a piano player reading from a score would be reading using a G key signature, then it's 5, 4, 1. I think it's useful to be able to think about it both ways. In fact if you listen to the original, I think it's clear that different soloists were effectively (by their choice of notes) thinking about it different ways.
It's generally annotated in G - think "Play the Greatest Hits for Piano" book type of thing. This leads to the most efficient transcription. That's great, but not the only way to think about it. In most situations, I think about it as in D and based on a blues/mixolydian scale. But I started out as a blues guitarist, and think about a 1, b7, 4 type of progression as being keyed in the 1 chord. When I form a mental image, I'm thinking about choosing the scale notes from D mixolydian, although I admit I'm not thinking modes, that's just a the particular mode that goes with the notes that "go over" that song. But even that doesn't really cover it - the blue notes modify that thinking.
I would take bets that Skynyrd was not reading this song from a score, and I doubt they ever have. But if a symphony played it (shudder the thought!), I bet they'd be reading a score in G.
- Rich Upright
- Posts: 1183
- Joined: 30 Sep 2014 9:55 am
- Location: Florida, USA
- Joachim Kettner
- Posts: 7523
- Joined: 14 Apr 2009 1:57 pm
- Location: Germany
- Doug Beaumier
- Posts: 15642
- Joined: 4 Aug 1998 11:00 pm
- Location: Northampton, MA
- Contact:
- Doug Beaumier
- Posts: 15642
- Joined: 4 Aug 1998 11:00 pm
- Location: Northampton, MA
- Contact:
As for the story of Ed King playing his guitar solo in G, even though the song is in D, Kooper said, "IMHO, the song is in they key of D. Ed disagrees and says its in the key of G. We are both talking about the same finished recording. It is an opinion about an existing piece of music."
Some stories say Kooper tried to change the solo to D in the mixing process, but King won out. "Neither of us wishes to 'fix the key,' Kooper said, "the discussion is an interpretation of what each of us hears. Ed IS playing his solo in they key of G while in my opinion the song is in D. That causes some interesting note rubs but I got used to them after a few hours because Ed refused to change the solo in ANY way."
- chris ivey
- Posts: 12703
- Joined: 8 Nov 1998 1:01 am
- Location: california (deceased)
-
- Posts: 774
- Joined: 1 Jan 2014 7:09 pm
- Location: Oklahoma City, Ok, USA
-
- Posts: 435
- Joined: 10 Dec 2012 10:57 am
- Location: New Jersey, USA
I think some of the confusion stems from the fact that D major pentatonic(d e f# a b), D minor pentatonic (d f g a c )and G major pentatonic (g a b d e ) all work well for soloing.I'm thinking the g minor pentatonic won't work so well , mainly because of the e flat.I hope this is
accurate, because I just came home from a gig where they let us eat and drink for free, and I did. As stated earlier by someone else , Gmajor and D mixolydian have the same notes,and will work well
accurate, because I just came home from a gig where they let us eat and drink for free, and I did. As stated earlier by someone else , Gmajor and D mixolydian have the same notes,and will work well
Last edited by Joseph Napolitano on 13 Jul 2015 5:47 am, edited 1 time in total.
- Richard Sinkler
- Posts: 17067
- Joined: 15 Aug 1998 12:01 am
- Location: aka: Rusty Strings -- Missoula, Montana
-
- Posts: 435
- Joined: 10 Dec 2012 10:57 am
- Location: New Jersey, USA
- Dave Mudgett
- Moderator
- Posts: 9648
- Joined: 16 Jul 2004 12:01 am
- Location: Central Pennsylvania and Gallatin, Tennessee
Yeah, a bunch of tunes use this same type of 1, b7, 4 type of progression. E.g., Dear Mr. Fantasy, which I think most people think of as in D because it comes back to D in the verse, i.e., D, C, G, D, and thus just slightly less ambiguous. But I'll bet it would also be annotated in G, again because it's easier. To me, there are other issues with the concept of "key-center" besides what makes it easiest to annotate. To me, it's about, "Where is home?".
So let's just say that I agree with Al Kooper, for my own purposes - home is D for me. I really think part of this is how you think about the tune. I think of it as blues-based, i.e., more pentatonic/mixolydian, rather than major-scale based. And I never did like that majory solo on it - it's a blues-based rock and roll tune and that major scale feel just never fit, to my ears. I'd even almost go so far as to say that it feels "wrong" to me, and always did. But this seems to me to be sort of the inverse issue of blues/rock guitar players playing strict blues pentatonics over a very major-scaley country tune - and I know plenty who also insist on doing that. Arghhh. Yeah, I know it's all about perspective. But to me, it's all about, "When in Rome ...".
I also admit, if I never had to play this song again, it would be too soon. To be honest, I'd even rather play Free Boid.
So let's just say that I agree with Al Kooper, for my own purposes - home is D for me. I really think part of this is how you think about the tune. I think of it as blues-based, i.e., more pentatonic/mixolydian, rather than major-scale based. And I never did like that majory solo on it - it's a blues-based rock and roll tune and that major scale feel just never fit, to my ears. I'd even almost go so far as to say that it feels "wrong" to me, and always did. But this seems to me to be sort of the inverse issue of blues/rock guitar players playing strict blues pentatonics over a very major-scaley country tune - and I know plenty who also insist on doing that. Arghhh. Yeah, I know it's all about perspective. But to me, it's all about, "When in Rome ...".
I also admit, if I never had to play this song again, it would be too soon. To be honest, I'd even rather play Free Boid.
- chris ivey
- Posts: 12703
- Joined: 8 Nov 1998 1:01 am
- Location: california (deceased)
-
- Posts: 3009
- Joined: 1 Dec 1998 1:01 am
- Location: LA,CA
Well, as a piano player I kind of enjoy playing the solo and channeling Billy Powell. Good thing is, I only may have to do it once every 10 years or so. If I'm lucky.
As far as the key, when I do a solo, I think D...when I'm comping I hear it in G...especially if I listen to the bass.
As far as Skynyrd...can't say that I've ever been a fan, but when I was touring with Chris Hillman in '76 we did a handful of shows with them and they were absolutely awesome...at the top of their game. Went on their plane once...didn't fly on it...was just invited to check it out by Billy Powell one day in Billings, MT.
But that's another story...
As far as the key, when I do a solo, I think D...when I'm comping I hear it in G...especially if I listen to the bass.
As far as Skynyrd...can't say that I've ever been a fan, but when I was touring with Chris Hillman in '76 we did a handful of shows with them and they were absolutely awesome...at the top of their game. Went on their plane once...didn't fly on it...was just invited to check it out by Billy Powell one day in Billings, MT.
But that's another story...
D mixolydian. It's the same key signature as G (one sharp), but the root note is D. Lots of rock songs are like that - the b7 note is in the scale instead of the major7.
Try the listening test: if you end on G, it sounds unresolved. It naturally ends on D.
I don't need to play that song ever again.
Try the listening test: if you end on G, it sounds unresolved. It naturally ends on D.
I don't need to play that song ever again.
-𝕓𝕆𝕓- (admin) - Robert P. Lee - Recordings - Breathe - D6th - Video
- Dave Mudgett
- Moderator
- Posts: 9648
- Joined: 16 Jul 2004 12:01 am
- Location: Central Pennsylvania and Gallatin, Tennessee
- Bill Terry
- Posts: 2786
- Joined: 29 Apr 1999 12:01 am
- Location: Bastrop, TX
I'm not on pins and needles, hoping that song gets called, it loses it's charm after about the 3,000th rendition to a crowd of drunks.. However, the real problem I have is that most bands don't play it anywhere even close to the original version. They just learn the little D riff (incorrectly most of the time) and barge ahead.. amps on 10.
The real arrangement with all the little cool guitar interactions and subtleties (perhaps unintentional?) and subtle rhythmic stuff, is actually pretty neat IMO. It can actually be fun if you try to play it right, most bands just don't.
So it's not the song I hate, it's the zillions of crappy bar band versions.. Of course not everybody sees it that way, just my 0.02.
The real arrangement with all the little cool guitar interactions and subtleties (perhaps unintentional?) and subtle rhythmic stuff, is actually pretty neat IMO. It can actually be fun if you try to play it right, most bands just don't.
So it's not the song I hate, it's the zillions of crappy bar band versions.. Of course not everybody sees it that way, just my 0.02.
Lost Pines Studio
"I'm nuts about bolts"
"I'm nuts about bolts"
- Joachim Kettner
- Posts: 7523
- Joined: 14 Apr 2009 1:57 pm
- Location: Germany
Yes Bill, if you see it this way. I also notice the use of a B-Bender and the piano, (is it Al Kooper, Jon Light?) lightening the mood.
But the message as an answer song to "Southern Man" is dubious. I remember an album by Don Nix and the Alabama State Troupers, it was more of my taste.
But the message as an answer song to "Southern Man" is dubious. I remember an album by Don Nix and the Alabama State Troupers, it was more of my taste.
Fender Kingman, Sierra Crown D-10, Evans Amplifier, Soup Cube.