Tunings and intonation
Moderator: Shoshanah Marohn
- Søren Stevnsgaard
- Posts: 9
- Joined: 27 May 2014 8:42 am
- Location: Denmark
Tunings and intonation
Hi
I know this topic has been discussed quite in the past, but Im still in the need of advice on this. I've just upgraded my Stage One to a second hand WBS custom, and Im very excited with it. It sounds as good as I hoped in any way. But, it also showed me how bad I am at intonating, and how important it is to find the right tuning.
On the Stage One I used Petersons sweetened tuning that i programmed on my cleartune app, but practising for a studio recording, I experienced some challenges with intonation. I then tried just-intonation: http://www.b0b.com/infoedu/just_e9.html and Hybrid: http://www.larrybell.org/id32.htm, but they just gave me other problems. I ended up using the hybrid for the recording, and then worked the bar around it. It worked ok, and I know that i won't find a 'perfect tuning'. But I wanna find a good basic tuning, and then learn to use that, and maybe do my own small changes to it.
Questions: What tuning do you use and why? And, what do you do to compensate? ie moving bar, or avoiding pedal combinations, or specific chords?
Thanks,
/Soren
I know this topic has been discussed quite in the past, but Im still in the need of advice on this. I've just upgraded my Stage One to a second hand WBS custom, and Im very excited with it. It sounds as good as I hoped in any way. But, it also showed me how bad I am at intonating, and how important it is to find the right tuning.
On the Stage One I used Petersons sweetened tuning that i programmed on my cleartune app, but practising for a studio recording, I experienced some challenges with intonation. I then tried just-intonation: http://www.b0b.com/infoedu/just_e9.html and Hybrid: http://www.larrybell.org/id32.htm, but they just gave me other problems. I ended up using the hybrid for the recording, and then worked the bar around it. It worked ok, and I know that i won't find a 'perfect tuning'. But I wanna find a good basic tuning, and then learn to use that, and maybe do my own small changes to it.
Questions: What tuning do you use and why? And, what do you do to compensate? ie moving bar, or avoiding pedal combinations, or specific chords?
Thanks,
/Soren
- Scott Duckworth
- Posts: 3470
- Joined: 6 Apr 2013 8:41 am
- Location: Etowah, TN Western Foothills of the Smokies
- Contact:
Buddy Emmons Tempered Tuning
http://www.buddyemmons.com/ttchart.htm
I tried all the rest, and they didn't work.
http://www.buddyemmons.com/ttchart.htm
I tried all the rest, and they didn't work.
Amateur Radio Operator NA4IT (Extra)
http://www.qsl.net/na4it
I may, in fact, be nuts. However, I am screwed onto the right bolt... Jesus!
http://www.qsl.net/na4it
I may, in fact, be nuts. However, I am screwed onto the right bolt... Jesus!
If you're gonna record with other instruments, I recommend going closer to ET. Guitars, keys, fretted basses, most horns are all in ET.
Since I find ET thirds a tad jangly, I've gone to the following compromise: D#, E#, G# & C# all a mere 4 or 5 cents flat, everything else straight up.
Since I find ET thirds a tad jangly, I've gone to the following compromise: D#, E#, G# & C# all a mere 4 or 5 cents flat, everything else straight up.
2 pedal steels, a lapStrat, and an 8-string Dobro (and 3 ukes)
More amps than guitars, and not many effects
More amps than guitars, and not many effects
- Steve Lipsey
- Posts: 1900
- Joined: 9 May 2011 8:51 pm
- Location: Portland, Oregon, USA
- Contact:
I give a hearrty +1 to Lane's tuning....you will sound good with the band, and by yourself. It isn't "perfect", but neither is the world around us. It reduces the beats of chords by flatting thirds enough to sound good, but no so much that you sound bad with other instruments. And you can do it with a plain old boss TU-2 guitar tuner!! Just tune those thirds one light down from straight up...no programming, easy to see.
One mod I use is to NOT detune the C# that is string 5 with the C pedal - that typically is the root of a chord, not a third, and is better left straight up. Also, the E-F change should be flatter than the others (doesn't relaly matter how much) because it is a third to notes that are already flatted by the other adjustments, and so needs to go down a bit beyond them.
This method sounds great and it isn't critical at all to get the detuned notes exactly down by a specific amount - you won't hear it if they are off by a bit. The goal for the thirds is just to reduce the beats, not to be exactly in tune iwth anything...
This method was incredibly liberating, and sounds great with the band...what more could you ask?
Note that I'm not criticizing in any way the more complicated JI tunings - I'm just saying that this works for me and for others, and may be worth giving it a try...tuning is a very personal thing with this crazy instrument...
One mod I use is to NOT detune the C# that is string 5 with the C pedal - that typically is the root of a chord, not a third, and is better left straight up. Also, the E-F change should be flatter than the others (doesn't relaly matter how much) because it is a third to notes that are already flatted by the other adjustments, and so needs to go down a bit beyond them.
This method sounds great and it isn't critical at all to get the detuned notes exactly down by a specific amount - you won't hear it if they are off by a bit. The goal for the thirds is just to reduce the beats, not to be exactly in tune iwth anything...
This method was incredibly liberating, and sounds great with the band...what more could you ask?
Note that I'm not criticizing in any way the more complicated JI tunings - I'm just saying that this works for me and for others, and may be worth giving it a try...tuning is a very personal thing with this crazy instrument...
www.facebook.com/swingaliband & a few more....
Williams S10s, Milkman Pedal Steel Mini & "The Amp"
Ben Bonham "CooderNator" archtop parlor electric reso w/Fishman & Lollar string-through
Ben Bonham "ResoBorn" deep parlor acoustic reso with Weissenborn neck and Fishman
Ben Bonham Style 3 Tricone., 1954 Oahu Diana, 1936 Oahu Parlor Squareneck
Williams S10s, Milkman Pedal Steel Mini & "The Amp"
Ben Bonham "CooderNator" archtop parlor electric reso w/Fishman & Lollar string-through
Ben Bonham "ResoBorn" deep parlor acoustic reso with Weissenborn neck and Fishman
Ben Bonham Style 3 Tricone., 1954 Oahu Diana, 1936 Oahu Parlor Squareneck
- chris ivey
- Posts: 12703
- Joined: 8 Nov 1998 1:01 am
- Location: california (deceased)
- Søren Stevnsgaard
- Posts: 9
- Joined: 27 May 2014 8:42 am
- Location: Denmark
- James Holland
- Posts: 228
- Joined: 2 Feb 2012 7:49 pm
- Location: Alabama, USA
Vocals, fiddles, trombones and steel guitars CAN do JI thirds.
BUT if there are keys and fretted instruments around, they might not want to. Competing thirds can clash. Remember that guitars often play SHARP thirds, since oversqueezing the strings will sharp them.
BUT if there are keys and fretted instruments around, they might not want to. Competing thirds can clash. Remember that guitars often play SHARP thirds, since oversqueezing the strings will sharp them.
2 pedal steels, a lapStrat, and an 8-string Dobro (and 3 ukes)
More amps than guitars, and not many effects
More amps than guitars, and not many effects
-
- Posts: 21192
- Joined: 16 Feb 1999 1:01 am
- Location: Glen Burnie, Md. U.S.A.
I tune JI, and don't try to "sweeten" anything. If there are a few intervals and chords that don't sound good, then I just don't play them...or I substitute something simpler that is in tune.
The world isn't going to end (and I'm not going to get fired) if I can't play a 7-note chord, like a minor 11th, in perfect tune.
The world isn't going to end (and I'm not going to get fired) if I can't play a 7-note chord, like a minor 11th, in perfect tune.
-
- Posts: 34
- Joined: 8 Jan 2009 1:50 pm
- Location: Aarhus, Denmark
Steve, you mentioned using a Boss TU-2 tuner, and I would like to do the same, using the tuning that Lane and yourself describe. But how many cents is one light on a Boss TU-2?
I am currently using a TU-3, which has more lights than the TU-2... so how many cents is one light on the TU-3?
I found no answer in the owners manual...
I am currently using a TU-3, which has more lights than the TU-2... so how many cents is one light on the TU-3?
I found no answer in the owners manual...
Thank you Donny - that's heartening. I tune my U12 in JI because natural intervals are what attracted me to the steel, and ET is what repels me from the piano. As a consequence my 7th string is too sharp to use as the root of F#m - but there are plenty of other minors. String 5 has two C# raises - one for pedal A to give the A/B chord and one for P7 which is slightly sharper to match string 7. I love the sound I'm getting. I did tune to ET once as an experiment, but only once.Donny Hinson wrote:I tune JI, and don't try to "sweeten" anything. If there are a few intervals and chords that don't sound good, then I just don't play them...
Make sleeping dogs tell the truth!
Homebuilt keyless U12 7x5, Excel keyless U12 8x8, Williams keyless U12 7x8, Telonics rack and 15" cabs
Homebuilt keyless U12 7x5, Excel keyless U12 8x8, Williams keyless U12 7x8, Telonics rack and 15" cabs
Ask, if you are a smartphone user, there are plenty of free tuner apps (if you have an 1/4" to 3.5mm adapter, you can plug the steel into the mic input of your computer, and there are both Windows and Mac tuner apps).
You could also try tuning the E major chord by ear and checking how flat the 6th and third strings are (if you tune til it sounds the sweetest, it'll be 8 cents flat), and tune the E#, G#, D# and C# to HALF that flat.
I'm not familiar with the tuners you have.
You could also try tuning the E major chord by ear and checking how flat the 6th and third strings are (if you tune til it sounds the sweetest, it'll be 8 cents flat), and tune the E#, G#, D# and C# to HALF that flat.
I'm not familiar with the tuners you have.
2 pedal steels, a lapStrat, and an 8-string Dobro (and 3 ukes)
More amps than guitars, and not many effects
More amps than guitars, and not many effects
-
- Posts: 34
- Joined: 8 Jan 2009 1:50 pm
- Location: Aarhus, Denmark
- Michael Coggins
- Posts: 90
- Joined: 8 Nov 2013 5:31 pm
- Location: Sligo, Ireland
Just checked my TU-3 against my Seiko cent tuner...Ask Kjaergaard wrote:Steve, you mentioned using a Boss TU-2 tuner, and I would like to do the same, using the tuning that Lane and yourself describe. But how many cents is one light on a Boss TU-2?
I am currently using a TU-3, which has more lights than the TU-2... so how many cents is one light on the TU-3?
I found no answer in the owners manual...
1 light = 5 cent
2 lights = 10 cent etc
Mullen Royal Precision SD10, 2002 Fender Telecaster, Alden Mandocaster, Boss Katana 100-212, Stage One V/P, Tom Bradshaw Resonator Pedal. Wampler Paisley Drive, Wampler Ego Compressor, Boss Super Chorus, Simble Overdrive.
-
- Posts: 34
- Joined: 8 Jan 2009 1:50 pm
- Location: Aarhus, Denmark
- Steve Lipsey
- Posts: 1900
- Joined: 9 May 2011 8:51 pm
- Location: Portland, Oregon, USA
- Contact:
Ask-
I use 1 light down from in-tune on the TU-2 and use the pair of lights lit just below the green in-tune light on the TU-3. I actually use the TU-3 mostly.
So i guess I'm using about 7 cents down. That seems to balance reducing the audible beats in a chord as much as I can while still being in tune with guitars in band....you can pick your own comfort level on this.
I leave the tuner plugged in to the volume pedal tuner out and always on - easy to quickly check tuning in between songs....and the big lights on the Boss are easy to see, don't have to look for a needle and figure out where it is on a scale...plus the TU-3 has a nice "superbright" mode which is great when playing outside in a sunny place...
I really use A+F and other "difficult" chord forms a lot, which this tuning completely allows, because it isn't looking for perfection in other forms....especially where "perfection" is out of tune with the guitars in the band...there are lots of ways to think about tuning, Lane's way lets me sound fine and play with the band and use all the lever/pedal combos, although you can hear the "imperfections" if you play by yourself and listen for them....just like a 6-string guitar now sounds really out of tune to me now, since I've learned to hear the beats in the chords....but that is the way the world tunes, so I just go with it...(for the A+F change, remember to tune the E->F raise another set of lights down to make it work as a third with the notes that are already tuned down)
I use 1 light down from in-tune on the TU-2 and use the pair of lights lit just below the green in-tune light on the TU-3. I actually use the TU-3 mostly.
So i guess I'm using about 7 cents down. That seems to balance reducing the audible beats in a chord as much as I can while still being in tune with guitars in band....you can pick your own comfort level on this.
I leave the tuner plugged in to the volume pedal tuner out and always on - easy to quickly check tuning in between songs....and the big lights on the Boss are easy to see, don't have to look for a needle and figure out where it is on a scale...plus the TU-3 has a nice "superbright" mode which is great when playing outside in a sunny place...
I really use A+F and other "difficult" chord forms a lot, which this tuning completely allows, because it isn't looking for perfection in other forms....especially where "perfection" is out of tune with the guitars in the band...there are lots of ways to think about tuning, Lane's way lets me sound fine and play with the band and use all the lever/pedal combos, although you can hear the "imperfections" if you play by yourself and listen for them....just like a 6-string guitar now sounds really out of tune to me now, since I've learned to hear the beats in the chords....but that is the way the world tunes, so I just go with it...(for the A+F change, remember to tune the E->F raise another set of lights down to make it work as a third with the notes that are already tuned down)
www.facebook.com/swingaliband & a few more....
Williams S10s, Milkman Pedal Steel Mini & "The Amp"
Ben Bonham "CooderNator" archtop parlor electric reso w/Fishman & Lollar string-through
Ben Bonham "ResoBorn" deep parlor acoustic reso with Weissenborn neck and Fishman
Ben Bonham Style 3 Tricone., 1954 Oahu Diana, 1936 Oahu Parlor Squareneck
Williams S10s, Milkman Pedal Steel Mini & "The Amp"
Ben Bonham "CooderNator" archtop parlor electric reso w/Fishman & Lollar string-through
Ben Bonham "ResoBorn" deep parlor acoustic reso with Weissenborn neck and Fishman
Ben Bonham Style 3 Tricone., 1954 Oahu Diana, 1936 Oahu Parlor Squareneck
- Sid Hudson
- Posts: 861
- Joined: 16 Jul 2011 7:48 am
- Location: Virginia, USA
- Contact:
- Bob Russell
- Posts: 511
- Joined: 1 Jun 2011 10:14 pm
- Location: Virginia, USA
- Contact:
-
- Posts: 34
- Joined: 8 Jan 2009 1:50 pm
- Location: Aarhus, Denmark
- Steve Lipsey
- Posts: 1900
- Joined: 9 May 2011 8:51 pm
- Location: Portland, Oregon, USA
- Contact:
I don't play C6- you can use the theory behind this method to give it a try... Or maybe Lane has some advice....
www.facebook.com/swingaliband & a few more....
Williams S10s, Milkman Pedal Steel Mini & "The Amp"
Ben Bonham "CooderNator" archtop parlor electric reso w/Fishman & Lollar string-through
Ben Bonham "ResoBorn" deep parlor acoustic reso with Weissenborn neck and Fishman
Ben Bonham Style 3 Tricone., 1954 Oahu Diana, 1936 Oahu Parlor Squareneck
Williams S10s, Milkman Pedal Steel Mini & "The Amp"
Ben Bonham "CooderNator" archtop parlor electric reso w/Fishman & Lollar string-through
Ben Bonham "ResoBorn" deep parlor acoustic reso with Weissenborn neck and Fishman
Ben Bonham Style 3 Tricone., 1954 Oahu Diana, 1936 Oahu Parlor Squareneck
-
- Posts: 8173
- Joined: 3 Jan 2002 1:01 am
- Location: Buffalo, N.Y.
- Contact:
Learning to play a steel guitar in tune is an art. Some people just don't have the ears for it and will never get it. Being in tune doesn't men that you can play a steel guitar in tune. I've seen master players play wildly out of tune steels at outdoor concerts in tune with bar adjustments. It's an instinct. It took me years and some advice from master players to understand this. This borders on something that can't be taught. It's like Zen.
- Clete Ritta
- Posts: 2005
- Joined: 5 Jun 2009 6:58 pm
- Location: San Antonio, Texas
I often play along with a Roland digital keyboard in ET. I check my tuning on E9 open strings with a Boss TU-2 just like that too. Everything green (straight) but strings 3 and 6 one red light left of center (sweetened flat).Steve Lipsey wrote:...tune those thirds one light down from straight up...
The pedals and levers rarely need adjusting. I tuned them by ear so it sounds good. Similar to the Emmons chart by the looks of it but never checked exact cents.
I thought horns were closer to JI. Don't they play natural overtones of the harmonic series?Lane Gray wrote:...most horns are all in ET...
Søren Stevnsgaard wrote:...what do you do to compensate? ie moving bar, or avoiding pedal combinations, or specific chords?...
All pedal/lever combinations are valid. The chords produced are where you will discover what works and what does not with each combination. For instance, when using A/F pedal/lever combo with your major chord grips, it sometimes sounds more in tune by positioning the bar slightly towards the left side of the fret instead of directly over it. This is an example of a compensation for tuning.
Last edited by Clete Ritta on 12 Jun 2015 3:57 am, edited 1 time in total.