Page 4 of 4

Posted: 15 Nov 2011 8:30 pm
by Lane Gray
Herb Steiner wrote:
Lane Gray wrote:I'd say they both crossed beyond their genres to become the broader culture's caricature of banjo music and 70s pretensions rock.
My candidate for the iconic popular conception of banjo music is "Dueling Banjos," by Reno and Smith, visually represented by that unfortunate creature with the family tree that doesn't fork in "Deliverance."

The big breakthrough for FMB was as the chase music in "Bonnie and Clyde," though it was the inferior 1960's version. Earl's 1950 cut on Mercury was the best, and the first. And sold the least.

Of course, who amongst us could forget that Lester and Earl's other significant contribution to our culture was "The Ballad of Jed Clampett." The Beverly Hillbillies, basically a Snuffy Smith cartoon played by live actors, was the redneck Gilligan's Island. Or did "Green Acres" fill that niche? Hmmm... I don't recall banjo on "GA," so I'll go with the Hillbillies.

So, until the Osbornes hit with "Rocky Top," when the regular civilian heard a banjo, he thought 1) the Keystone Kops were chasing somebody; 2) Granny and Jethro were out by the cement pond, or worst of all 3) somebody's being told they've got a "pretty mouth," and y'all know the rest.

As to pretentious rock, I'm not conversant enough with the genre to have an opinion, although I'd have to say that ACDC's "Shook Me All Night Long," has to be up there, based on having to play it every night in the 1980's in a country cover/dance band.

While working in a music store during that period of time, the songs most wanked upon by every pre-pubescent-through-late-teen kid who had to play every freakin' guitar in the store were "Smoke On The Water," "My Sharonna," and "STH."
There. Fixed Yer Post
;-) ;-)

Posted: 15 Nov 2011 8:50 pm
by Herb Steiner
Lane, I know who wrote the song, I played bluegrass from 1960 until 1968. And regardless of the composers, the "hit" version was by Eric Weissberg and Marshall Brickman. So we are both correct.

However, I really have a problem with you quoting me and then altering the post and making it look more to your liking, from an ethical point of view. You could post additional information in any other way. But to change my writing in the form you did is the best way to have me quit posting my opinions. Uncool, and I am outta this thread. Bye.

Posted: 15 Nov 2011 8:58 pm
by Lane Gray
My apologies, Herb. In several different forums (fora?) I'm in, that is an accepted device combining humor and discussion.
And I'd submit that I didn't do it sneakily, but told anyone reading it that I'd done so. I'd certainly not meant to ruffle your feathers or irritate in any way.
Like I said, in other communities I'm part of, an accepted device. I'll not employ it on your words again (probably on nobody's here save Sinkler, who seems to think like me)

Posted: 23 Nov 2011 11:50 pm
by Bo Legg
I'm sad when things go this way in a topic but then again I'm happy when Stuart or I weren't to blame. :lol: