bigsby/clinesmith style blade PU vs. horseshoe
Moderator: Brad Bechtel
- Jon Nygren
- Posts: 322
- Joined: 18 Jun 2008 10:21 am
- Location: Wisconsin, USA
bigsby/clinesmith style blade PU vs. horseshoe
Have any of you guys played/play both guitars that use these pickups?
And to those of you who have- what do you feel are the differences and similarities?
I'm getting close to pulling the trigger on a clinesmith. Just curious to hear some opinions as I play a guitar with post war shoes most of the time.
And to those of you who have- what do you feel are the differences and similarities?
I'm getting close to pulling the trigger on a clinesmith. Just curious to hear some opinions as I play a guitar with post war shoes most of the time.
Last edited by Jon Nygren on 25 May 2010 4:31 am, edited 2 times in total.
-
- Posts: 6877
- Joined: 5 Jan 2005 1:01 am
- Location: Nanuet, NY
- Contact:
I've played 3 Clinesmiths pretty extensively (2 consoles and 1 lap steel) and probably a dozen Rickenbachers. I've had a few Rickenbacher gems--a Frypan and a B6--that were outstanding, and I played Rick Aiello's A-25 Frypan which is the cream of the crop, but I was not all that in love with the other 8 or 9. It's a real gamble, but when you get a good one it's pretty special.
The Clinesmiths have been very consistent in both tone and playability. Two things I can tell you about the Clinesmiths: they have a good amount of bite with body (it's not just superficial highs, but a real nice resonance that extends across a wider upper mid); and they are slightly microphonic, so the pickup sounds alive. It is definitely not a dead sounding pickup. I find the output to be slightly hot, not overwhelming to the point of overdriving your input of clipping, and I find it balanced nicely across the spectrum, aside from the little bump in the upper mids.
As far as the Rickenbachers, of the pickups I really liked, there was almost a compressed kind of sound where the attack was not quite immediate. It was very pleasing in some ways. I also found the frequency response of the ones I liked to be extended in both the highs and lows. The mids (from say 600 to 1k) seemed to have a slight dip, from what I recall, but it's been a while. The Rickenbachers sounded best with older amps (think early Epiphone and tweed Fenders) and maybe a little too bright with the blackface and onward Fenders.
Just my $.02 for what it's worth--may not be worth much more than that.
The Clinesmiths have been very consistent in both tone and playability. Two things I can tell you about the Clinesmiths: they have a good amount of bite with body (it's not just superficial highs, but a real nice resonance that extends across a wider upper mid); and they are slightly microphonic, so the pickup sounds alive. It is definitely not a dead sounding pickup. I find the output to be slightly hot, not overwhelming to the point of overdriving your input of clipping, and I find it balanced nicely across the spectrum, aside from the little bump in the upper mids.
As far as the Rickenbachers, of the pickups I really liked, there was almost a compressed kind of sound where the attack was not quite immediate. It was very pleasing in some ways. I also found the frequency response of the ones I liked to be extended in both the highs and lows. The mids (from say 600 to 1k) seemed to have a slight dip, from what I recall, but it's been a while. The Rickenbachers sounded best with older amps (think early Epiphone and tweed Fenders) and maybe a little too bright with the blackface and onward Fenders.
Just my $.02 for what it's worth--may not be worth much more than that.
-
- Posts: 6877
- Joined: 5 Jan 2005 1:01 am
- Location: Nanuet, NY
- Contact:
- Jon Nygren
- Posts: 322
- Joined: 18 Jun 2008 10:21 am
- Location: Wisconsin, USA
Thanks for the description Mike, it helps alot. The part I bolded gets me excited- I love PU's that are a bit microphonic and I like the fact that the blade PU isnt too ovewhelming to your input...if there's one beef about the shoes in the guitar I have, it pummels the front end just a bit too much with some amps.Mike Neer wrote:
The Clinesmiths have been very consistent in both tone and playability. Two things I can tell you about the Clinesmiths: they have a good amount of bite with body (it's not just superficial highs, but a real nice resonance that extends across a wider upper mid); and they are slightly microphonic, so the pickup sounds alive. It is definitely not a dead sounding pickup. I find the output to be slightly hot, not overwhelming to the point of overdriving your input of clipping, and I find it balanced nicely across the spectrum, aside from the little bump in the upper mids.
.
... so... if I were say... looking for a Bakelite on ebay I could quite possibly end up with a horseshoe that doesn't sound totally awesome? I guess I kinda figured they were all gems.Mike Neer wrote:I've played 3 Clinesmiths pretty extensively (2 consoles and 1 lap steel) and probably a dozen Rickenbachers. I've had a few Rickenbacher gems--a Frypan and a B6--that were outstanding, and I played Rick Aiello's A-25 Frypan which is the cream of the crop, but I was not all that in love with the other 8 or 9.
If Music Be the Food of Love, Play On. -Shakespeare
___________________________________________
1941 Ric B6 / 1948 National Dynamic / 1951 Bronson Supro / Custom teak wood Allen Melbert / Tut Taylor Dobro / Gold Tone Dojo / Martin D15S / Eastman P10
___________________________________________
1941 Ric B6 / 1948 National Dynamic / 1951 Bronson Supro / Custom teak wood Allen Melbert / Tut Taylor Dobro / Gold Tone Dojo / Martin D15S / Eastman P10
- Bob Hoffnar
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: 4 Aug 1998 11:00 pm
- Location: Austin, Tx
- Contact:
I went through about 8 bakelite Rickys before I started playing Clinesmith steels. We are talking about 60 year old guitars here. The pickups may need a little juicing up sometimes. The bakelites are amazing sounding guitars. Something special about them that nothing really replicates. With that I found the sound, craftsmanship and playability of the Clinesmith to be vastly superior to even the most holy grail of pre war bakelites I owned. I have never owned a frypan though.
My feeling about pickups (and I build them) is that they only do so much. They are a small part of what makes a steel sound good. Because a horse shoe sounds good in a Ricky it does not mean it will make another steel sound like a bakelite. Think of pickups like microphones. Switching mics will not make Johnny Cash sound like Nora Jones.
My feeling about pickups (and I build them) is that they only do so much. They are a small part of what makes a steel sound good. Because a horse shoe sounds good in a Ricky it does not mean it will make another steel sound like a bakelite. Think of pickups like microphones. Switching mics will not make Johnny Cash sound like Nora Jones.
Bob
I love that analogy!Bob Hoffnar wrote:Switching mics will not make Johnny Cash sound like Nora Jones.
As a side note, I checked out the Clinesmith site but didn't notice any lap steels there. Console and Weissenborn-style only from the looks of it.
I am looking for a good second lap steel to learn C6 on. I was thinking it would be worth my while to get something collectible I guess...
If Music Be the Food of Love, Play On. -Shakespeare
___________________________________________
1941 Ric B6 / 1948 National Dynamic / 1951 Bronson Supro / Custom teak wood Allen Melbert / Tut Taylor Dobro / Gold Tone Dojo / Martin D15S / Eastman P10
___________________________________________
1941 Ric B6 / 1948 National Dynamic / 1951 Bronson Supro / Custom teak wood Allen Melbert / Tut Taylor Dobro / Gold Tone Dojo / Martin D15S / Eastman P10
You absolutely could wind up with a dog. I've played a few that were (but only 2 or 3). I had one that I had rewound that still never sounded good to me.J. Wilson wrote: ... so... if I were say... looking for a Bakelite on ebay I could quite possibly end up with a horseshoe that doesn't sound totally awesome? I guess I kinda figured they were all gems.
-
- Posts: 6877
- Joined: 5 Jan 2005 1:01 am
- Location: Nanuet, NY
- Contact:
- Mark Roeder
- Posts: 895
- Joined: 25 Sep 2007 11:22 am
- Location: Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA
I'd echo everything said about the Clinesmith. I bounce between a 53 Stringmaster ,Gibson Grande Console and the Clinesmith. The Fender and Gibson have things about them I like, but the Clinesmith is what I play the most.
www.deluxe34.com lap steel stands, Clinesmith, Gibson Console Grande, Northwesterns, The Best Westerns
https://www.facebook.com/TheBestWesterns
https://www.facebook.com/TheBestWesterns
- Mark Roeder
- Posts: 895
- Joined: 25 Sep 2007 11:22 am
- Location: Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA
Jon
I don't know where in Wisconsin you are, but if your near Madison sometime look me up and you can play my Clinesmith till your satisfied.
I don't know where in Wisconsin you are, but if your near Madison sometime look me up and you can play my Clinesmith till your satisfied.
www.deluxe34.com lap steel stands, Clinesmith, Gibson Console Grande, Northwesterns, The Best Westerns
https://www.facebook.com/TheBestWesterns
https://www.facebook.com/TheBestWesterns
-
- Posts: 3740
- Joined: 29 Oct 2002 1:01 am
- Location: Saginaw, Michigan, USA (deceased)
The bakelites are sure not all great sounding, but it's hard to figure out why. I've had 4, and the T logo 7 string I have now sounds quite good. The horseshoe seems to match a dense material in a guitar body. The wood types I built with the horseshoe didn't sound any better than having a DiMarzio in there.
-
- Posts: 695
- Joined: 25 Apr 2008 12:59 pm
- Location: Various places
- Contact:
Does this mean you recharged the magnets? If so, how do you go about doing this? What are the associated costs?Andrew Roblin wrote:All sounded much better after regaussing.
Also, when you say they sounded much better... do you mean 'awesome'? Or just 'better'? The Bakelites I have heard all sound incredible... but I guess no one posts a video of a Bakelite that sounds crappy!
If Music Be the Food of Love, Play On. -Shakespeare
___________________________________________
1941 Ric B6 / 1948 National Dynamic / 1951 Bronson Supro / Custom teak wood Allen Melbert / Tut Taylor Dobro / Gold Tone Dojo / Martin D15S / Eastman P10
___________________________________________
1941 Ric B6 / 1948 National Dynamic / 1951 Bronson Supro / Custom teak wood Allen Melbert / Tut Taylor Dobro / Gold Tone Dojo / Martin D15S / Eastman P10
- Jon Nygren
- Posts: 322
- Joined: 18 Jun 2008 10:21 am
- Location: Wisconsin, USA
-
- Posts: 695
- Joined: 25 Apr 2008 12:59 pm
- Location: Various places
- Contact:
I had the magnets regaussed. Bobbe Seymour has someone who does this. Mine were done by a Forum member who has been keeping a low profile. I'm going to respect his privacy.
After regaussing, all the pickups sounded awesome.
But not every Ricky steel has the bakelite magic. Some of the different body materials and instrument designs don't sound as fine as the bakelite. And my impression is that bakelite Rickys sound best with string-through design.
On some Ricky pickups the pole pieces don't line up well on the lowest string, resulting in less volume.
After regaussing, all the pickups sounded awesome.
But not every Ricky steel has the bakelite magic. Some of the different body materials and instrument designs don't sound as fine as the bakelite. And my impression is that bakelite Rickys sound best with string-through design.
On some Ricky pickups the pole pieces don't line up well on the lowest string, resulting in less volume.
-
- Posts: 40
- Joined: 30 Sep 2009 7:19 am
- Location: Massachusetts, USA
- Contact:
Scantic River Lap Steel Guitars
Check out Scantic River Lap Steel Guitars. They are handcrafted using the best components. We make a Chicago Series with a Lollar Chicago Steel Pickup That sounds Amazing. www.Scanticriverguitars.com Regards Tom